PvP, Flags and Notoriety
Fighting other captains, choosing a flag and what raises your notoriety.
Reputation and PvP
Fighting other captains at sea is a chance to plunder them, earn Battle Marks and XP, complete missions, and try your nerve and luck.
Reputation determines which bonuses you get in faction towns and what happens when you sink players
Red players: pirates and those on bad terms with your faction. Sink them lawfully and earn rewards.
Yellow players: those on neutral terms with your faction. Sinking them may bring penalties.
Green players: your allies, or unguilded players on good terms with your faction. Sinking them can bring a severe penalty.
In port battles, in the Endless Sea, and when the other ship attacked first, sinking doesn’t affect reputation
Black Spots are given for sinking neutral players or ships of a much different rate. Players in military factions get a reputation penalty instead of a Spot.
Flags
Flags let you choose a play style, turn PvP protection on or off, grant XP and loot bonuses, and give access to certain ports.
PvP protection does not work in the center of the map (inside the red circle) and in the Endless Sea.
Under PvP protection, when several players sink an NPS, the loot is split by damage dealt, or you get a chance to fight for all of it
Notoriety Level
Many NPS (non-player ships) play an important role in the economy, even though they’re constantly sunk for profit
Sinking NPS in daylight, especially merchantmen, raises your Notoriety Level! It drops over time.
As your Notoriety Level grows, ships will attack you more often, and in time, bounty hunters come out too
Text from the game's in-game help (Gamepedia).