Ammunition compared
Which ammo does the most damage depends on the target's armor, because penetration minus armor is multiplied by the ammo's damage factor. High-penetration ammo gains the most against heavily armored ships; high-damage-factor ammo wins against light ones.
Heavy shot vs Saxon shot vs Cast-iron shot
| Ammo | Damage factor | Reload | Ball speed | Sail damage | Crew damage | Special |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cast-iron shot | ×1.0 | ×1.0 | ×1.0 | 3.5 | 0.2 | can start fires |
| Heavy shot | ×1.25 | ×1.4 (slower) | ×1.1 | 3.5 | 0.2 | none |
| Saxon shot | ×0.8 | ×1.0 | ×1.2 | 8 | 0.8 | overpenetration, extra minor fires |
| Carcass shells | ×0.9 | ×1.0 | ×1.0 | 7 | 0.2 | fire area, extra minor fires, 60% range |
- Heavy shot hits 25% harder per ball, but its 40% longer reload means about
89% of cast-iron's damage per minute. Heavy shot adds no penetration, so its edge is the same against any armor. It wins on burst: one broadside into a stern or a nearly sunk ship. It cannot start fires.
- Saxon shot does 20% less per ball, but its faster ball is easier to land at range, it
overpenetrates into a ship behind, shreds sails and crew more, and starts extra minor fires. It is the better choice for setting up a large fire, for crowded fights and before boarding. For raw hull damage per minute, cast-iron is ahead (×1.0 vs ×0.8).
- Cast-iron shot gives the best sustained hull damage per minute of the three.
- Chain shot and grapeshot are for sails and crew, not the hull.
Compare them yourself
The Battle simulator has a Compare ammo button: pick your cannon and a target ship and it lists per-ball damage (side, bow and stern) and damage per minute for every ammo type.